Top Rated Stories in category:
Anal
| Rank | Title & Author | Rating (Votes) |
|---|---|---|
| 51. | Helen and Alex - a Holiday Swansong One last time before flying home again. by LucyDrees (07/07/23) | 4.71 (95) |
| 52. | My First Threesome Anal threesome beyond my wildest dreams. by El_Fazee3 (10/06/23) | 4.70 (493) |
| 53. | Oz Beach Boy Butts Bikini Babe Matt takes a busty bikini gal in the butt under the sun... by MyBareTorso (08/18/23) | 4.70 (184) |
| 54. | My 10-Inch Lover Trans romance, no violence, all sex consentual among adults. by erectus123 (12/04/23) | 4.69 (95) |
| 55. | Cocksleeve IG Robbie is a virgin - until Saffire takes him in hand... by AlexBarton2 (12/15/23) | 4.69 (95) |
| 56. | Guilt Best Man called into Action as Wedding Collapses. by LiteraryRanger (11/28/23) | 4.69 (229) |
| 57. | The Elites Ch. 01 - The Anal Expert Jon can make women have earth-shattering anal orgasms! by 3angle (06/13/23) | 4.69 (169) |
| 58. | Moonkiss Captured by barbarians - but is he truly a prisoner? by Devinter (12/03/23) | 4.69 (109) |
| 59. | The Elites Ch. 03 - Synorax Jon discovers perpetual erection. by 3angle (08/13/23) | 4.68 (38) |
| 60. | The Boyfriend Pt. 55 Tasha surprises Liam and hangs out while he has a plug in. by taylorstorms (09/17/23) | 4.68 (38) |
| 61. | A Work Affair: Jess and Eric Jess and Eric's affair begins as Eric explores all of Jess. by littlebettysbangs (08/15/23) | 4.68 (289) |
| 62. | Hot for Teacher Sexy teacher learns about anal pleasure. by Dazman (02/04/24) | 4.68 (141) |
| 63. | A Fantastic Summer Ch. 05 Dylan settles into his new job. by Unencumbered (09/19/23) | 4.68 (147) |
| 64. | The Fisherman's Shack Pt. 02 The hardcore filth continues. by Dazman (08/16/23) | 4.68 (50) |
| 65. | Return to the Haunted House Pt. 01 Sarah encourages voyeurism while offering her butt. by Dazman (02/05/24) | 4.68 (37) |
| 66. | Miss Allison Ch. 06 David revels in filthy, nasty anal sex. by soppingwetpanties (01/02/24) | 4.68 (154) |
| 67. | Amazing Neighbors Pt. 04 The next chapter in the Amazing Neighbors tale. by tulsatime39 (10/28/23) | 4.67 (129) |
| 68. | I was a Teenage Gigolo This is historical fiction, based loosely on actual events. by readwrite (11/13/23) | 4.67 (104) |
| 69. | Cokewhore Ch. 05 - Her Ass Destroyed Johnny takes Kelsey's anal virginity- on camera! by HobstockleGrin (11/02/23) | 4.67 (122) |
| 70. | Pillow Princess Club Ch. 15 Pussies 24-25: MILF discovers the joys of anal sex. by silkstockingslover (05/10/24) | 4.67 (181) |
| 71. | 25yo/75yo Do More than Talk Sex 75yo recalls youthful sex. 25yo shows him sex with viagra. by Satsumabook123 (03/17/24) | 4.67 (69) |
| 72. | Never be the same Poor straight guy gets abused by an older couple. by H1tsthespot (02/26/24) | 4.67 (209) |
| 73. | Red Dragon My wife invites a man to fulfill a fantasy... and my asshole. by EStaccato (08/23/23) | 4.66 (104) |
| 74. | Raya and Devin's Journey Pt. 01 Raya and Devin's journey starts with open discussion. by Dragonflame22 (01/11/24) | 4.66 (56) |
| 75. | Birthday Butt Play Michael's wife gives him some anal love on his birthday. by RandomSmut (02/26/24) | 4.66 (333) |
| 76. | Jase and Beth: Anal Exploration With vaginal sex out of the question Beth tries other holes. by KelleyR (02/12/24) | 4.66 (99) |
| 77. | Happy Birthday, Erica Pt. 02 Happy birthday, Dominic. by WeldinMike27 (06/06/23) | 4.66 (29) |
| 78. | An Escort's Chastity Cuckold Ch. 02 Dahlia's relationship with Her cuckold moves forward. by geeklove (11/08/23) | 4.65 (81) |
| 79. | Leah An Old Affair. Renewed. by chicagomike1 (10/01/23) | 4.65 (83) |
| 80. | Five Mums Ch. 50 - Dance Lesson A dance Lesson and I get to know Natasha. by milfman23 (03/11/24) | 4.65 (40) |
| 81. | The Wingman Nic's roommate needs a wingman. by N0tg8 (03/20/24) | 4.65 (157) |
| 82. | The Roommate Pt. 61 Lexi fucks Marie into subspace, then gives her a challenge. by taylorstorms (07/12/23) | 4.65 (62) |
| 83. | Emma and Bobbie Like Anal Sex David satisfies their needs. by ElectricBlue (10/18/23) | 4.64 (90) |
| 84. | Sex Shop Slut: Fucking Nicks Ass Zara's first experience pegging a man. by TwistedManc (12/08/23) | 4.64 (227) |
| 85. | Allie's Adventures Pt. 03 - Punishment Allie enjoyed getting caught. Will she enjoy being punished? by Ella_Andrews (01/30/24) | 4.64 (56) |
| 86. | Georgie's Road A bi guy helps his girlfriend with her intimacy issues. by sub_marine (02/20/24) | 4.64 (92) |
| 87. | Nina's Sister Jake meets an old flame's sister. This flame is a 5-alarm. by JakeRockwell (09/19/23) | 4.64 (459) |
| 88. | Amber 07 After a long day together two lovers explore other pleasures. by jkpolk (02/18/24) | 4.64 (86) |
| 89. | Man Does More than Decorate Ch. 02 More anal adventures for young wife and older man. by Satsumabook123 (05/28/23) | 4.64 (127) |
| 90. | Any Given Sunday Wife surprises me with the craziest day ever. by Beastieboy9 (10/20/23) | 4.64 (165) |
| 91. | The Start of Something Fun - Take 04 Olivia Gives Matt a Massage. by Cocktail7307 (05/26/23) | 4.64 (85) |
| 92. | Professional Dirty Secrets A guy I worked with and his mate DP me and payEscort stories. by JezzicaDee (10/16/23) | 4.63 (126) |
| 93. | Butt Coin Ch. 02 Marty gets kidnapped and is forced to make Butt Coin. by LadyBuxom (11/04/23) | 4.63 (38) |
| 94. | Me Too - Kamila Kamila is seduced by a producer and loses her anal virginity. by MohanSingh (11/30/23) | 4.63 (38) |
| 95. | Rummates Pt. 10 Roommates share some drinks and a hot guy. by JimBob44 (10/12/23) | 4.63 (84) |
| 96. | Kate Pt. 02 I dive deeper into Kate's simmering sexuality. by LukeWrites (11/06/23) | 4.63 (73) |
| 97. | S.L - The Secret Courier Erika tricks her secretary into being an anal courier! by Becky_Sapphire (03/17/24) | 4.63 (154) |
| 98. | Tyler Ch. 04: More Women Tyler Responds with Cock to More Women. by ZachDocEight (05/31/23) | 4.63 (97) |
| 99. | A Work Affair: Jess and Eric Ch. 02 It's the Monday after Jess & Eric's first sexual encounter. by littlebettysbangs (08/17/23) | 4.63 (140) |
| 100. | Butt Coin Ch. 04 Maria forces Marty to work a Butt Coin Gang Bang Party. by LadyBuxom (12/17/23) | 4.63 (35) |
