Top Rated Stories in category:
First Time
| Rank | Title & Author | Rating (Votes) |
|---|---|---|
| 51. | No Worries Two troubled teens face their feelings for each other. by Benjamin_Winter (12/31/18) | 4.84 (1790) |
| 52. | The Witches of Huntington Widower meets the neighbor girls. by Frankenstein1962 (11/20/21) | 4.84 (1661) |
| 53. | Alice and I An old friend comes back to town. by clarkcrow (07/22/17) | 4.84 (1426) |
| 54. | A Cancelled Date Things go very well for me when Chloe's date cancels on her. by Bottom_side_up (08/06/22) | 4.84 (1331) |
| 55. | Locker Room Dare Ch. 01 A dare takes a crazy turn for a high school geek. by m_storyman_x (12/09/23) | 4.84 (1279) |
| 56. | Sofia Vietnam vet, girl with learning disabilities, lifelong love. by R410a (04/25/20) | 4.84 (1006) |
| 57. | The Hacker and the Slacker Girl trades for hacker services. by SilverFoxMullet (06/24/22) | 4.84 (737) |
| 58. | Isabel, The Beauty Next Door Pt. 04 Life can be a roller-coaster. by Bamo68 (04/09/21) | 4.84 (655) |
| 59. | The Marine Bk. 02 Ch. 07 Nate protects a young woman during his next assignment. by UltimateSin (09/07/22) | 4.84 (614) |
| 60. | Chinese Takeout Ch. 04 Baby Blue - Jay-Lin heads off for her workout at Quebec's. by ChloeTzang (05/29/16) | 4.84 (560) |
| 61. | Pining for Madison A school assignment changes everything. by Secretauthor2021 (02/22/24) | 4.84 (385) |
| 62. | Then and Now Pt. 01 Young woman has an erotic encounter skinny dipping. by Maydaypilot (03/16/23) | 4.84 (349) |
| 63. | Diary of a Horny Student Ch. 12 Tim learns the truth about Steph's first time. by LiminallySpaced (09/01/22) | 4.84 (313) |
| 64. | Love is Being Stupid Together Ch. 01 Science nerd and computer geek explore sex. by RicknCenFl (01/22/24) | 4.84 (312) |
| 65. | Understanding Sonia Archie works to understand the very complicated Sonia. by PickFiction (12/03/21) | 4.84 (270) |
| 66. | Niece Rindi Ch. 08 - The Prom The Senior Prom. by Lightninrod (12/27/22) | 4.84 (112) |
| 67. | Trailer Trash Ch. 03 Does rich boy finally get the Trailer Trash girl? by Slickman (09/29/06) | 4.83 (4122) |
| 68. | Runaway Pt. 02 One bed, one virgin, and one unforgettable train ride. by MsCherylTerra (03/18/20) | 4.83 (1556) |
| 69. | Band Camping This one time while camping... by rexspaulding (06/06/18) | 4.83 (1335) |
| 70. | Memories Of Our Babysitter Ch. 04 Cass tells our secret to a friend - the last chapter. by jasperspen (10/13/19) | 4.83 (1321) |
| 71. | Natalie's House: First Time Fuck I take a young man's virginity as a favor to his aunt. by IsabellaEmily (08/26/21) | 4.83 (921) |
| 72. | The Girl from the Ouachita Ch. 02 I'll never forget the night I met the girl from the Ouachita. by Texican1830 (02/14/22) | 4.83 (863) |
| 73. | Chinese Takeout Ch. 05 Listening for the Weather. by ChloeTzang (07/22/16) | 4.83 (844) |
| 74. | Tucker's Studio Ch. 13 Cinnamon Sugar by riverboy (03/06/16) | 4.83 (763) |
| 75. | You're Alex? Alex decided to make some changes in her life. by PickFiction (06/19/21) | 4.83 (642) |
| 76. | The Girl from the Ouachita Ch. 05 When you're on top of the world... by Texican1830 (03/07/22) | 4.83 (629) |
| 77. | Teenage Fantasy Ch. 02 A cliche romance between a football player and his nerd. by SunflowerThorns (02/08/23) | 4.83 (591) |
| 78. | Ashley My childhood babysitter is even more fun as an adult. by Leader12 (04/12/24) | 4.83 (554) |
| 79. | Saturday Night Five Ch. 03 Can Leo finally lose his virginity? by johnrocker_lit (04/25/23) | 4.83 (547) |
| 80. | F is for Fail Chinese Parents Set a High Standard for Success. by ChloeTzang (05/05/21) | 4.83 (511) |
| 81. | Memories Of Our Babysitter Ch. 06 Cass' sister turns out to be as curious as Cass. by jasperspen (11/11/21) | 4.83 (506) |
| 82. | Zeb's First Time Experiences Zeb details some of the first time sexual experiences! by silverfern (09/18/20) | 4.83 (469) |
| 83. | Virgin Freshman from the Farm Kyle's horizons expand when he leaves the farm for college. by badge_25 (05/10/23) | 4.83 (367) |
| 84. | Claire's Invitation Pt. 03 My college girlfriend makes a decision. by HighPlainsEros (01/16/21) | 4.83 (333) |
| 85. | The Lady Next Door Pt. 02 Another new neighbor adds to the new experiences. by RonCabo (09/19/22) | 4.83 (322) |
| 86. | Parts of Desire Ch. 04 A teenage fantasy comes true in the Arabian desert. by thatsbogus (02/22/19) | 4.83 (225) |
| 87. | Colton Stories - Gus and Adi Ch. 02 Gus and Adi explore their new relationship. by BadWriter75 (08/23/22) | 4.83 (197) |
| 88. | Groupie (her) Sweet and sensual way to lose virginity. Multiple orgasms. by Omenainen (05/13/20) | 4.83 (186) |
| 89. | Tybalt and Juliet Ch. 15 Finale. by SpindleTop (05/15/20) | 4.83 (181) |
| 90. | The Awakening of Jennifer Pt. 03 Jennifer's friend Julia visits. by Ophelia_Coque (12/15/22) | 4.83 (126) |
| 91. | Summer in Amber Ch. 06 Miss Amber puts Jacob to the ultimate test. by BryndenBlackstone (04/08/20) | 4.83 (104) |
| 92. | Army Brat Ch. 06 Army base game and romance. by Slickman (10/30/08) | 4.82 (3061) |
| 93. | Camp Natural Cameron learns the nudist life with help from two girls. by storyteller19 (07/13/19) | 4.82 (2391) |
| 94. | You are Definitely Going to Hell Rob, loses more than his virginity. by Bamo68 (02/08/22) | 4.82 (1254) |
| 95. | No Tan Lines Winter in Florida, a Girl, a Guy, and a Boat. by ChloeTzang (12/07/19) | 4.82 (1177) |
| 96. | Graduation Ch. 02 Caleb invites Penny to his home for some personal training. by member9458 (05/16/17) | 4.82 (1098) |
| 97. | You're In My Seat Pt. 04 Ally and Carter reach a finale. by JaneSaysIt (03/09/16) | 4.82 (939) |
| 98. | Mutual Benefits Ch. 10 The most popular girl in school needs a study buddy. by BashfulScribe (10/05/21) | 4.82 (890) |
| 99. | Me and Mrs. G I lust after my landlady. by Slowandeasy47 (10/02/22) | 4.82 (707) |
| 100. | Sosoni Ch. 04 Feral woman must make a choice. by fsqueeze (07/13/19) | 4.82 (685) |
