Top Rated Stories in category:
First Time
| Rank | Title & Author | Rating (Votes) |
|---|---|---|
| 101. | Chinese Takeout Ch. 02 High School Pickup - Jay-Lin goes for a ride with Round Out. by ChloeTzang (01/13/16) | 4.82 (672) |
| 102. | The Girl from the Ouachita Ch. 04 Jo rising above her raising. by Texican1830 (03/02/22) | 4.82 (638) |
| 103. | My Angel of Mercy Love and Lust can be powerful healers... by eidetic (03/03/17) | 4.82 (630) |
| 104. | Every Christmas Needs a Virgin Angela gets an unexpectedly wonderful Christmas gift. by vanmyers86 (11/30/19) | 4.82 (610) |
| 105. | Four Inches In a question of height, which ones count. by AFoolRushesIn (05/02/21) | 4.82 (556) |
| 106. | Fitting In Pt. 02 The first time, a wedding, family. by R410a (07/23/20) | 4.82 (493) |
| 107. | Bathers and Black Squirrel A retired professor reminisces about young love lost. by carrteun (10/25/19) | 4.82 (413) |
| 108. | Dogpile An awkward young man receives a text from an old friend... by AlwaysUnderfoot (07/27/22) | 4.82 (356) |
| 109. | My Valentine You're all I need, my love, my Valentine… by ChloeTzang (02/09/23) | 4.82 (311) |
| 110. | Diane's Inamorato Tutee Charlie loses his virginity to a talented masseuse. by GentlemanFlynn (07/27/23) | 4.82 (282) |
| 111. | Cold Beer, Boiled Shrimp, New Love A college romance born in 1976 after spring day of revelry. by RoyceFHouton (04/22/24) | 4.82 (253) |
| 112. | Grandpa's Guide to Women Pt. 10 Our story concludes with a romantic reunion of Ben and Beth. by JQueen9 (06/16/23) | 4.82 (188) |
| 113. | Erin's Wild Week Pt. 03 - Biology Class Erin and Amanda are tardy but make it up to their teacher. by emelle78 (06/25/23) | 4.82 (147) |
| 114. | Crucifix: Temptation Ch. 06 Brody & Claudia's sorrow, their reunion, their joy. by Browniepoints (06/27/06) | 4.82 (105) |
| 115. | That's What Friends Are For Justin's best friend Samantha will do anything for him. by lovecraft68 (03/29/14) | 4.81 (34933) |
| 116. | Waiting in Line for the New iPad Waiting outside the Apple Store becomes a magical experience. by MaxSebastian (05/09/13) | 4.81 (6938) |
| 117. | 1BR Apt. She could be just the thing. by Member389 (11/30/12) | 4.81 (3881) |
| 118. | Goodbye, La La Land Gary and Kathleen discover 'Real Life' together. by MLyons (11/09/04) | 4.81 (3588) |
| 119. | Tomboy Ch. 05 Tom and Jo must make an important decision. by Slickman (04/11/05) | 4.81 (2956) |
| 120. | Fingerprints on My Heart A Chinese girl, a married man and a kind of romance. by ChloeTzang (03/20/17) | 4.81 (2804) |
| 121. | Runaway Pt. 01 A religious small-town girl breaks free. by MsCherylTerra (03/17/20) | 4.81 (1621) |
| 122. | The Demon Queen of Hell The consequences of banging the Demon Queen of Hell. by blackrandl1958 (03/17/21) | 4.81 (1577) |
| 123. | A Handyman's Memoir Ch. 26 The girls next door. by riverboy (07/26/14) | 4.81 (1283) |
| 124. | Once is an Accident I took my friend Tess's virginity by accident. by thegratian (08/20/21) | 4.81 (1151) |
| 125. | Harrowing Halloween Chris's best friend is beautiful, smart, and also a ghost. by storyteller19 (10/24/18) | 4.81 (1130) |
| 126. | Belle Are there really 44 year old virgins? by R410a (09/05/20) | 4.81 (804) |
| 127. | Loving Eyes Sometimes it's foreign eyes that see most clearly. by Sir Galahad (02/02/14) | 4.81 (746) |
| 128. | A Serendipitous Reunion Desperation leads to a fantasy fulfilled. by Member389 (06/28/22) | 4.81 (676) |
| 129. | Maleficent A sexy witch leaves a shy guy frustrated by Trionyx (10/01/21) | 4.81 (607) |
| 130. | The Girl from the Ouachita Ch. 06 What doesn't kill you makes you stronger. by Texican1830 (03/13/22) | 4.81 (601) |
| 131. | You are Definitely Going to Hell Ch. 04 Robs life gets more complicated. by Bamo68 (11/12/22) | 4.81 (558) |
| 132. | Leaving Home Pt. 02 Claire teaches her young man how to make love. by R410a (06/08/22) | 4.81 (474) |
| 133. | Meaningful, Meaningless Sex She went to Spain to lose her virginity. by SpindleTop (10/16/20) | 4.81 (466) |
| 134. | My Best Friend Alice Pt. 02 A weekend with Alice changes everything. by Secretauthor2021 (09/28/23) | 4.81 (442) |
| 135. | Under the Milky Way Confessing love to a best friend is never straight forward. by Thefireflies (03/21/20) | 4.81 (387) |
| 136. | Dorm Room Games Group of nerdy college kids play a sexy game. by xxavi (01/22/24) | 4.81 (316) |
| 137. | The Salon Ch. 02 Donna receives a surprise tip from Jeremy. by stevetruestories (12/11/15) | 4.81 (280) |
| 138. | Warrior Princess Love and war in Anglo-Saxon England. by SpindleTop (08/07/21) | 4.81 (259) |
| 139. | Colton Stories - Gus and Adi Ch. 01 A Colton College love story. by BadWriter75 (08/23/22) | 4.81 (228) |
| 140. | Jeong Park's First Frosh Ball Ch. 10 Give Your All To Me. by ChloeTzang (08/04/22) | 4.81 (156) |
| 141. | Dormant Desires Pt. 03 Four freshman boys give a mom a perfect night of pleasure. by becca20S (07/01/23) | 4.81 (153) |
| 142. | My Brother's Best Friend Ch. 05 Feline encounters trouble at the Circle K, loving sex ensues. by LV4206 (12/07/21) | 4.81 (142) |
| 143. | Paige Teaches Perversion Pt. 02 Paige continues to teach Austin about kink. by IsabellaEmily (02/07/24) | 4.81 (141) |
| 144. | Olympic Dreaming Ch. 04 A trip to France and meeting Mai. by Woodentop (12/12/23) | 4.81 (100) |
| 145. | A Thankful Blizzard Pt. 03 Being stuck in a cozy cabin with a girl can't be too bad, right? by rexspaulding (05/26/14) | 4.80 (1558) |
| 146. | A Handyman's Memoir Ch. 14 Meeting Julia by riverboy (06/29/14) | 4.80 (1443) |
| 147. | I Really Can't Stay What will people think, doll? by MsCherylTerra (12/04/20) | 4.80 (1240) |
| 148. | Precious Jules Some things are rarer than gems, love is a good example. by Member389 (05/20/17) | 4.80 (1038) |
| 149. | Chinese Eyes Sand, sea and surfing and a sweet Chinese girl in Oz by ChloeTzang (07/04/18) | 4.80 (785) |
| 150. | The Virgin Valentine Ryan's V-Day gift from Gwen takes an unexpected turn. by Vaginalpuppetry (01/24/18) | 4.80 (738) |
