Top Rated Stories in category:
First Time
| Rank | Title & Author | Rating (Votes) |
|---|---|---|
| 101. | Sex Shop Slut Innocent Catholic girl finds herself in a sticky situation. by TwistedManc (09/01/23) | 4.71 (829) |
| 102. | Company Mandated Stress Relief Since when did anger management include face fucking? by iwiwt (08/28/23) | 4.71 (129) |
| 103. | A Friend In Need My wife and I help a sexually frustrated friend. by silverfern (06/27/23) | 4.70 (627) |
| 104. | The Suburban Mom Pt. 07 Marcia introduces Connor to Vesna. by The_Veil_of_Isis (07/06/23) | 4.70 (100) |
| 105. | A Fantastic Summer Ch. 03 Mrs. Napolitano gives Dylan an unexpected gift. by Unencumbered (08/15/23) | 4.70 (253) |
| 106. | Sister Margaret A young sinner has sex with his favorite nun. by yesterdays (10/29/23) | 4.70 (319) |
| 107. | Veronique Goes Sailing Ch. 05 Veronique gets to see Sally taken by the guys. by Mingemuncher (07/09/23) | 4.70 (89) |
| 108. | P.O.R.N. Mateo pops his porn cherry. by WaltzSmut (10/26/23) | 4.70 (46) |
| 109. | Olympic Dreaming Ch. 08 Sabrina and the Mall. by Woodentop (12/17/23) | 4.70 (82) |
| 110. | Damian Ch. 03: READY, FIRE, AIM The one where Tara helps Damian's perspective. And manhood. by flynn99 (08/21/23) | 4.69 (13) |
| 111. | My Virgin Summer Four teens decide to lose their virginity before college. by WendyTrilby (07/14/23) | 4.69 (438) |
| 112. | Catching Up With Luke Ashley goes farther with Luke, despite her friends warnings. by wetfanatic (09/03/23) | 4.69 (55) |
| 113. | Road Trip 02: Off the Mat Danny reunites with an old flame who helps him move forward. by NomdePlumer (04/11/24) | 4.69 (42) |
| 114. | Harry Herrick's Naked Summer Pt. 02 Harry plans his first time with Ann. by fabfables (05/16/24) | 4.69 (48) |
| 115. | The Sleeping Bag Two friends explore their desire for one another. by MichaelCarrie (11/01/23) | 4.69 (450) |
| 116. | She keeps it in friend’s family Ch. 02 After friend, friends father now her friends virgin son. by Satsumabook123 (10/31/23) | 4.69 (83) |
| 117. | Me and Judy - and her Mom! Judy's Mom wants some action too by book_man_03 (08/28/23) | 4.69 (793) |
| 118. | Hormone Therapy Ch. 21 Ellie’s sister Emma and her mother Elizabeth. by sperm_donorX (02/27/24) | 4.69 (35) |
| 119. | The Newest Neighbors Pt. 07 Marin is really getting more daring. Mitch's friends agree. by richbigpenis (12/27/23) | 4.68 (165) |
| 120. | The Babysitter Ch. 06 Jennifer takes Steven's virginity. by BigTitCumLover (09/06/23) | 4.68 (183) |
| 121. | Summer of '69 Best friends come of age together. by CanadianM (04/18/24) | 4.68 (350) |
| 122. | Wife Helped in Being Shared Curious about being shared, I iniated a seduction of a guy... by ThreesomeJoan (01/16/24) | 4.68 (182) |
| 123. | College Girlfriend to Remember Introducing my new virgin girlfriend to the joys of sex. by willwork4wine (12/29/23) | 4.68 (291) |
| 124. | Fragments 06 Younger yacht club member finds comfort with an older member. by BCJ111 (12/25/23) | 4.68 (75) |
| 125. | Rachel Rachel was my older sister's friend. by FLBeachbum69 (12/03/23) | 4.68 (510) |
| 126. | Handy Sophia is so handy, everybody takes advantage except Michael. by Elaine_Mature (01/17/24) | 4.68 (199) |
| 127. | Best Friends... with Benefits Best friends take things to a new level. by funwithabiguy (10/01/23) | 4.68 (454) |
| 128. | The First Blowjob After a few months of dating, they share their first blowjob. by FreyaGersemi (12/09/23) | 4.68 (324) |
| 129. | The Babysitter Ch. 05 Jennifer sits 18 year old step-brothers John and Steven. by BigTitCumLover (09/04/23) | 4.68 (145) |
| 130. | Only the Truth Pt. 02 Sadie and Mason get closer. by __Lisa__ (09/17/23) | 4.67 (86) |
| 131. | Where's the Free Use? A secret content creator and a secret slut. by BashfulScribe (09/28/23) | 4.67 (86) |
| 132. | I Was My Sister's Life Model Being a life model can be hard. by BobbiR (12/09/23) | 4.67 (282) |
| 133. | The Awakening of Nympho Jasmeet A virgin with nymphomania loses herself to three professors. by Delimity (01/07/24) | 4.67 (52) |
| 134. | Dreams Really Do Come True An improbable dream and the hunt for a mysterious admirer. by iwiwt (06/17/23) | 4.67 (110) |
| 135. | Grandpa's Guide to Women Pt. 08 This is really going to happen, isn't it? by JQueen9 (06/13/23) | 4.67 (183) |
| 136. | The Suburban Mom Pt. 06 Marcia turns the tables on the Pastor's wife. by The_Veil_of_Isis (07/03/23) | 4.67 (137) |
| 137. | Stewart's Best Week Ever: Monday In a week's time a bullied HS senior's life changes forever. by jrydher1 (07/14/23) | 4.67 (475) |
| 138. | Olivia Fucks her Friend's Dad Bruce and Olivia fuck for the first time - not the last. by UncleMark415 (12/20/23) | 4.67 (429) |
| 139. | Nerd Becomes a Cumslut Ch. 02 Ashley is a nerd but she wants to be a cumslut. by ExtremelyAnonymous (06/24/23) | 4.67 (292) |
| 140. | Boobs! A late-blooming tomboy’s life is changed by breasts. by regularguy13 (08/18/23) | 4.67 (279) |
| 141. | Nerd Becomes a Cumslut Ch. 03 Ashley is a nerd but she wants to be a cumslut. by ExtremelyAnonymous (02/27/24) | 4.67 (165) |
| 142. | Hubby's Adventures 05 Blondie gets first cock while Mother meets Mr. Rolling Pin. by Operation_Balls (01/16/24) | 4.67 (45) |
| 143. | Sophia's Choice Pt. 04 Petsi seduces Peter. by Alice_Nicol (06/24/23) | 4.67 (33) |
| 144. | Little Mermaid Ch. 07 Ugly girls feel stupid. by angiquesophie (05/16/24) | 4.67 (18) |
| 145. | A&C 05: Donna Exposed Donna reveals the secret of Thor's lost hammer. by AlexFourways (12/17/23) | 4.67 (15) |
| 146. | Grandpa's Guide to Women - Pt. 01 Grandpa Frank schools Ben on the art of dating coeds. by JQueen9 (05/29/23) | 4.66 (280) |
| 147. | Olympic Dreaming Ch. 07 First time with Naomi then Mai. by Woodentop (12/16/23) | 4.66 (89) |
| 148. | That Summer My introduction to adulthood. by vividlyyours (01/12/24) | 4.66 (391) |
| 149. | Annette Annette's conservative ideals are challenged by her desires. by AshCardiff (11/29/23) | 4.66 (213) |
| 150. | My Big Titty Goth Roommate What's a little mutual face fucking between friends? by iwiwt (09/08/23) | 4.66 (436) |
