Top Rated Stories in category:
First Time
| Rank | Title & Author | Rating (Votes) |
|---|---|---|
| 201. | The Perks of Being a Producer Ch. 01 Seducing the Virgin Starlet. by PersepolisGames (08/30/23) | 4.60 (149) |
| 202. | Old Bill - Pt. 01 18 year old me and 61 year old Bill. by HoneyBee_1974 (11/27/23) | 4.60 (305) |
| 203. | Wednesday Evenings with Babs Pt. 02 The seduction of me by Barbara continues. by secret_passion_49 (07/25/23) | 4.60 (78) |
| 204. | A First Spring Break Full of Firsts A man recalls his first spring break. by ovenguy (03/24/24) | 4.60 (83) |
| 205. | Lusty Legal Partners (LLP) Ch. 03 The Johnsons initiate his employee and his wife. by Pimanko (01/11/24) | 4.60 (148) |
| 206. | Farm Girl Amy Pt. 16 Amy and a night of firsts. by richbigpenis (11/14/23) | 4.60 (195) |
| 207. | Lesson Ch. 02 Teacher shows student how to please him. by SassyShellie (07/22/23) | 4.60 (110) |
| 208. | The House Group Leader's Wife Pt. 05 Marcia wears stockings to get her man. by The_Veil_of_Isis (10/22/23) | 4.60 (20) |
| 209. | Out of the Blue Ch. 02 - 15 minutes Sequal to 'Out of the blue'. by Valdedeorsum23 (12/03/23) | 4.60 (20) |
| 210. | The Naked Smile A shy, young American woman smiles at a local French woman. by stellanemryswild (12/27/23) | 4.60 (20) |
| 211. | Afternoon study session Rae wants to explore sex with her friend Tim. by FentrisRook (07/31/23) | 4.60 (277) |
| 212. | The Babysitter She is finally legal and wants him desperatly. by GretaLace (02/06/24) | 4.60 (469) |
| 213. | Veronique Goes Sailing Ch. 01 An innocent young virgin's awakening. by Mingemuncher (06/27/23) | 4.60 (192) |
| 214. | The Suburban Mom Pt. 11 Marcia confronts a homophobic former beauty queen. by The_Veil_of_Isis (07/20/23) | 4.60 (84) |
| 215. | Season of the Midnight Sun A young Viking experiences a bittersweet summer. by JulianDelacourt (09/09/23) | 4.59 (64) |
| 216. | Couple Fall for Huge Cock & Big Tits A straight couple fall for huge cock and big tits. by roxyblacksissy66 (10/29/23) | 4.59 (123) |
| 217. | One Last Friendly Sleepover Childhood friends reunite for a sweaty sleepover & 3way. by Z17Lucky (01/01/24) | 4.59 (218) |
| 218. | Vegas Nerd Pt. 04 Todd and Anna heat up. by richbigpenis (11/25/23) | 4.59 (132) |
| 219. | Immobilized Sarah becomes stuck trying to watch. by MichaelCarrie (11/17/23) | 4.59 (88) |
| 220. | Sophia's Choice Pt. 09 A game of truth and dare has life-changing consequences. by Alice_Nicol (07/12/23) | 4.59 (44) |
| 221. | Office Intern He was a sweet virgin boy that I couldn’t resist. by April602 (02/15/24) | 4.59 (454) |
| 222. | The Time I Accidentally Got Locked Being a flight Attendant I have hookups in different cities. by Flying_Bottom (09/23/23) | 4.59 (39) |
| 223. | First Time Cuck and Bi My friend and I have fun sharing my wife and coaxed into bi. by Cuckadoodle (02/14/24) | 4.59 (228) |
| 224. | Thank You, Mrs. Pollard Ch. 02 The training continues. by HotJim (09/24/23) | 4.59 (155) |
| 225. | Sophia's Choice Pt. 07 Sophia finally gets to fuck the au pair. by Alice_Nicol (07/06/23) | 4.59 (29) |
| 226. | It's Never Too Late Two high school friends make up for lost time. by Plenipotentiary (07/02/23) | 4.59 (186) |
| 227. | The Suburban Mom Pt. 10 Connor must prove his leadership credentials to elder's wife. by The_Veil_of_Isis (07/16/23) | 4.59 (82) |
| 228. | Work Experience a Few Weeks Later My education continues. by helen_surrey (01/10/24) | 4.58 (108) |
| 229. | Berglund's Pt. 03 The two new hires passed the test. by richbigpenis (01/18/24) | 4.58 (36) |
| 230. | It Barely Fit We had an awkward start, but made up for it in bed. by insatiablerob8 (07/25/23) | 4.58 (283) |
| 231. | Chy, the Shy Babysitter Something exciting with the babysitter. by Coati29 (09/15/23) | 4.58 (584) |
| 232. | Birthday Present for Jeffery Jeff will always remember the girl that took his viginity. by W_E_Sinful (07/06/23) | 4.58 (112) |
| 233. | Sandy Ch. 02 Best friends become better friends. by ktingram18 (02/12/24) | 4.58 (157) |
| 234. | The Virgin Neighbour Naughty cougar takes neighbour's virginity. by MitziNorton (05/16/24) | 4.58 (88) |
| 235. | Wednesday Evenings with Babs Pt. 01 I lose my virginity to a 42 year old co-worker. by secret_passion_49 (07/21/23) | 4.58 (164) |
| 236. | Virgin Gamer Girl A gamer girl loses her virginity to an older game. by MohanSingh (11/23/23) | 4.58 (76) |
| 237. | Runaway Fantasy Pt. 05 A teen girl dreads the conclusion of her getaway. by becca20S (11/23/23) | 4.58 (19) |
| 238. | Camping Fun 03 - Year of the Sister Hannah’s sister Abby gets a turn this year. by QBall1184 (11/12/23) | 4.58 (234) |
| 239. | Out of My League Ch. 04 Meeting a real showoff. by iwiwt (02/18/24) | 4.58 (52) |
| 240. | A New Golf Partner and Hole in One Man and woman become partners who can keep secrets. by storyteller4u2 (09/27/23) | 4.58 (319) |
| 241. | A New Perspective Ch. 02 Chris and Leslie explore a reversal of roles. by mgrif024 (10/07/23) | 4.58 (85) |
| 242. | Jason - My Sister's Boyfriend Virginity surrendered for a second time? by thelastenglishking (07/21/23) | 4.58 (250) |
| 243. | Kerry-Ann Books a Sensual Massage Kerry-Ann's FBSM with Francesca a naturist masseuse. by Francesca_Care__Shares_Erotica (09/05/23) | 4.58 (106) |
| 244. | Curious A married man has his first gay encounter. by Dog_style (11/04/23) | 4.57 (216) |
| 245. | Sports Massage A massage virgin no longer... by steviex00 (01/06/24) | 4.57 (352) |
| 246. | The Domestic Help Interracial relationship. by BillyB100 (04/30/24) | 4.57 (183) |
| 247. | Country Club Romance Meeting at the Country Club. by snk2fly (03/14/24) | 4.57 (197) |
| 248. | The Blonde Beauty Pt. 02 Nerd tries to take advantage of busty blonde classmate. by TheBustyBard (05/20/23) | 4.57 (145) |
| 249. | Losing my Anal Virginity to Nichole How buttplugs and dildos lead me to lose my anal virginity. by SluttyMatthew (09/21/23) | 4.57 (149) |
| 250. | Breaking News Ch. 03 A virgin college co-ed gets more than her stocking stuffed. by UhlBWett (09/12/23) | 4.57 (51) |
